The same person in the QuickBooks file and on the acquisition call
In one week with the same client, I mapped CCC accounts into QuickBooks line by line, helped structure a calibration bonus program, and ran the math on what adding a fourth location does to the timeline for hiring a regional manager.
I want to talk about why that range is not a flex. It is how the work actually has to be built.
When a collision operator decides to change how his business runs, the engagement does not stay at one altitude. It moves. One morning I am in the accounting file deciding whether a PDR job should sit in labor or sublet, because the way it is coded today makes sublet margin look worse than it is. That afternoon the same distinction shows up in a conversation about a technician bonus, because you cannot pay people against a number you do not trust. A few weeks later that same margin picture is part of whether a fourth location pencils.
Want insights like this in your inbox?
Subscribe to the Collision Advisory newsletter. Financial strategy and industry analysis for collision repair operators, delivered weekly.
The account mapping is not separate from the incentive plan. The incentive plan is not separate from the growth math. They feed each other. Clean books are what make a bonus program measurable. A measurable bonus program is what makes the next-store decision something better than a guess. If those three live with three different people, the owner becomes the translator, and the owner already has a job.
This is the part most fractional CFO arrangements get wrong. They pick a lane, either strategy or cleanup. The owner gets a senior conversation once a month and junior delivery the rest of the time. The detail and the strategy drift apart, and the person paying for both is the one holding them together.
Logan Martin runs Mr. Dent Collision Repair across multiple locations. He is the kind of operator who thinks six to twelve months ahead and still drops into store-level problems more than he wants to. He hired me to build the financial operating system underneath that, and he hired me to do all of it. The same person in the QuickBooks file is the person on the acquisition call. That is on purpose.
I asked Logan if I could share what this looks like from his side. Here is what he said:
"I didn't want a CFO who shows up once a month with a slide deck. Doug is in my QuickBooks and CCC files rebuilding my chart of accounts, and he's also the guy I call when I'm thinking about store number four. Same person, same conversation. That's why I went with him."
That is the engagement I want to be hired for. Not a lane. The whole stack, held by one person, so the operator does not have to.
If you are weighing this kind of build for your own shop, send me a message. I am happy to walk through what it would look like.

Doug Higgins
Founder, Collision Advisory
Former CFO at Kroger's Midwest Division and CEO of TAG Auto Group. Doug brings institutional financial rigor to the collision repair industry.
Connect on LinkedInMore from From the Founder
Why I sit on the Down Syndrome Indiana board
People who follow my work for the finance read sometimes ask why a fractional CFO spends his time on a Down syndrome nonprofit. The honest answer is the most personal one I have: my son Beau.
From the Founder: The People Behind What I'm Building
A personal note on family, building a business, and making intentional time for the people who make the work possible.
What's Surprised Me Most About This Industry
I came from grocery. Kroger. Corporate finance. When I started working in collision, I expected a learning curve. What I didn't expect was the welcome.